The information flow in natural language syntax and semantics
establishes dependency patterns that go beyond the expressivity
of context-free grammars. Examples in syntax are discontinuous
dependencies as in long-distance displacement or cross-serial constructions.
In semantics, scope construal often appears to be out of sync
with syntactic composition.
In the tradition of extended rewriting systems, a family of grammar formalisms
has emerged that deals with such patterns in a graceful way. These so-called
'mildly context-sensitive' formalisms combine controlled expressivity beyond CF with
pleasant computational properties (polynomial parsability). In that sense, they
throw an interesting light on the computational limitations of the human language
processing device.
The thesis of this course is that we can gain a deeper understanding of these limitations
by modeling grammars as
substructural logics.
In a substructural logic, assumptions take the form of finite
material
resources that are effectively 'used up' in the
process of reasoning. We compare two recent resource-logical
developments that address the balance between expressivity and
complexity.
- Abstract Categorial Grammar (ACG): a compositional architecture
formulated in terms of intuitionistic multiplicative linear logic.
Surface forms and semantic
interpretations are derived from an abstract 'tectogrammatical'
source logic by means of compositional mappings. The Chomsky
hierarchy and its mildly context-sensitive refinements are
obtained in terms of a double complexity measure: the maximal
order of constants in the source logic, and the order introduced by
the mappings that send it to the target interpretations.
- Symmetric Categorial Grammar. ACGs are situated in the
intuitionistic world, where judgements have a single conclusion.
Symmetric categorial grammar goes beyond the intuitionistic restriction.
In addition to the tensor operation of context-free Lambek calculus ('merge', fusion)
one now has a dual fission operation; structure-preserving linear distributivity
principles control the communication between these two. On the level of
syntax, the distributivities establish information flow
between syntactically detached parts. On a semantic level,
grammaticality judgements are given a continuation-passing-style
interpretation. Continuation-based semantics makes the context an explicit component of
the computational process. As a result, apparent conflicts between
semantic construal and syntactic composition are resolved.
In the box some useful entries from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy to situate the course in a wider context.