Utrecht-Münster Seminar on Provability Algebras


PROGRAM


First meeting

DATE: 25.10.02; TIME:15:00 - 17:45.
LOCATION:
Department of Philopsophy, Utrecht University, Bestuursgebouw, Heidelberglaan 8, Room 043.
15:00
L. Beklemishev (Utrecht). Introduction and overview.
16:00
Coffee
16:20
C. Strohm (Münster). On Japaridze's logic GLP and its letterless fragment.

Abstract: Letterless formulas of GLP play the role of ordinal notations in the analysis of Peano Arithmetic based on graded provability algebras. They provide an alternative view of epsilon_0. Interrelations between ordinals and modal logic formulas will be discussed.

Reading:

  • L. Beklemishev. Provability algebras and proof-theoretic ordinals, I Section 3 (pp. 10-13).
  • Normal forms for the full closed fragment of GLP are given in: K.N. Ignatiev. On strong provability predicates and the associated modal logics. Journal of Symbolic Logic, 58:249-290, 1993. This part will not be needed for the understanding of further lectures.
17:20
Discussion and further plans.
17:45
Closing.

Second meeting

DATE: 15.11.02; TIME:X (not yet fixed)
LOCATION:
Institute for Mathematical Logic, Department of Mathematics, University of Münster, Einsteinstrasse 62, Room SR8 (8-th floor).
X
J. Joosten (Utrecht). The reduction property of graded provability algebras.

Abstract: The reduction property of GPA is an algebraic analog of cut-elimination. It states that a Pi_{n+2} sentence of the form <n+1>A has the same Pi_{n+1}-consequences as all the sentences {<n>A, <n>(<n>A & A), ... }. In particular, it generalizes the well-known theorem of Parsons on the conservativity of ISigma_1 over PRA.

Reading:

XX
Coffee
XXX
G. Lee (Münster). Independence of the Worm Principle.

Abstract: For a formulation of the Worm Principle see, e.g., here. The talk will cover the correctness and indepence proofs for the Worm Principle.

Reading: L. Beklemishev. Applications, a chapter on applications of provability logic to proof theory of arithmetic. Section 7.11, 7.12. Warning! This paper is still in an unfinished state.

XXXX
Discussion and further plans.
XXXXX
Closing.

Third meeting

DATE: 24.01.03; TIME:15:00 - 18:45.
LOCATION:
Institute for Mathematical Logic, Department of Mathematics, University of Münster, Einsteinstrasse 62, Room SR8 (8-th floor).
15:00
M. Möllerfeld (Münster). An introduction into impredicative proof theory and KP_omega.
16:30
Coffee
17:00
C. Duchhart (Münster). Continuation of the above.

Abstract:

KP_Omega is one of the relatively weak fragments of set theory that plays an important role in the theory of admissible sets. From the proof-theoretic point of view it is interesting, because it is one of the simplest examples of the so-called impredicative theories. Therefore, the calculation of the proof-theoretic ordinal of KP_Omega involves some significant novel features and, thus, is more difficult that the one of PA. By now, several methods have been developed to do this task. Moreover, KP_Omega has become a standard example to test the new methods. Ultimately, we are interested in developing the graded provability algebra approach to an extent sufficient for the analysis of KP_Omega. In the present talks we will start learning the basics of KP_Omega and its proof-theoretic analysis.

Starting with an introduction of some of the basic notions of generalized recursion theory (as there are $\omega_1^{CK}$, the first nonrecursive ordinal; Gödels constructible hierarchy $L$; inductive definitions; admissibility), we try to explain the ideas and results underlying impredicative proof theory. After that, we give some equivalent definitions of the proof-theoretic ordinal of an impredicative theory as an absolute measure of its strength. Finally, we treat the reductive proof theory of Kripke-Platek set theory (with infinity), $KP\omega$, and Kreisels theory of inductive definitions, $ID_1$, since both are paradigms of impredicative theories, thereby giving an overview of history and state-of-the-art of ordinal analysis.

Reading:

  1. W. Pohlers. Proof theory. An introduction. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 1407. Berlin etc.: Springer-Verlag. VI, 213 p.
  2. W. Pohlers. A short course in ordinal analysis. In: Aczel, Peter (ed.) et al., Proof theory. A selection of papers from the Leeds proof theory programme, an international summer school and conference on proof theory, held at the Leeds University, UK, from July 24-August 2, 1990. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 29-78 (1992).
  3. Jech: Set Theory (basic set theoretical notions)
  4. Barwise: Admissible Sets and Structures (admissibility & $KP\omega$)
  5. Moschovakis: Elementary Induction on Abstract Structures (inductive definitions)
18:30
Discussion and further plans.
18:45
Closing.

Fourth meeting

DATE: 14.02.03; TIME:15:00 - 18:00.
LOCATION:
Department of Philopsophy, Utrecht University, Bestuursgebouw, Heidelberglaan 8, Room 465.
15:00
L. Beklemishev (Utrecht). On various notions of proof-theoretic ordinals and provability algebras: a discussion.

Abstract: The talk is non-technical and mainly a discussion of issues around the `problem of natural ordinal notations'. I will discuss the notions of proof-theoretic ordinals, various pathological and non-pathological examples and the relations with the notion of graded provability algebra.

15:50
Coffee
16:15-18:00
C. Duchhardt, C. Heinatsch (Münster). A proof-theoretic analysis of KP_omega.

Abstract: The main ideas underlying the proof-theoretic ordinal analysis of KP_omega will be explained.

Reading: C. Duchhardt. Diplomarbeit. Münster, 2001.

18:00
Closing.